Video: Alan Shearer in complete agreement with Gary Neville over United’s Carrick conundrum

Former Premier League striker Alan Shearer has echoed Gary Neville’s view on how Manchester United should handle their Michael Carrick conundrum. Decision time Carrick has overseen a dramatic uptick in fortunes at United since he was named Ruben Amorim’s temporary replacement at the start of the year. It’s not just performances that have improved, but results as well. He masterminded a brilliant 3-2 victory over bitter rivals Liverpool on Sunday, marking his 10th win since taking charge of the team. Carrick has drawn two and lost just as many. ‘ The triumph over Liverpool not only secured a league double over the Merseyside club but also guaranteed United’s place in next season’s Champions League. The question now turns to United and what they intend to do with Carrick, who has made himself impossible to ignore. While Carrick is considered the frontrunner to secure the job on a permanent basis, United are adamant they will not make knee-jerk decisions. The club insists that an appointment will only get over the line once all available and suitable options have been secured. Other candidates believed to be in the running for the Old Trafford hot seat include Andoni Iraola, Julian Nagelsmann, Oliver Glasner and Gareth Southgate. But pressure is mounting on United to give Carrick the role. A recent report covered by The Peoples Person relayed that leading United figures like Harry Maguire, Bruno Fernandes and Matheus Cunha want Carrick to stay. Kobbie Mainoo said that he and his teammates are prepared to die on the pitch for the 44-year-old coach. Neville, a known opponent of Carrick’s appointment, made it clear that he could get behind his stay, but only under a short-term arrangement. Shearer has backed this stance. Shearer and Neville in agreement Speaking on the BBC, Shearer said, “They brought him in to do a specific job, and he has done that job very, very well.” “He’s won in big games as well. He’s beaten [Manchester] City, beaten Arsenal, beaten Liverpool.” “So for me, yes, he at least deserves the chance to go again. I don’t know, maybe a one-year contract with different incentives if he hits different targets. But he was brought in to do a job, and he’s done that job.” “He was brought in to do a job and he’s done that job.” ✅ Alan Shearer believes Michael Carrick deserves the chance to continue as Man Utd manager, but should he be given more than a one-year deal? 🤔 pic.twitter.com/zuTrFpf9lm — Match of the Day (@BBCMOTD) May 4, 2026 No club has collected more Premier League points than United since Carrick came in, which further highlights the magnitude of his influence. Featured image Alex Livesey via Getty Images The Peoples Person has been one of the world’s leading Man United news sites for over a decade. Follow us on Bluesky: @peoplesperson.bsky.social Derick Kinoti Derick Kinoti is a football writer at The Peoples Person who has covered Manchester United and the Premier League extensively for years. His work blends sharp analysis, tactical insight, and engaging storytelling that resonates with fans around the world. Derick has gained valuable experience in football journalism, developing strong expertise in SEO writing, digital content creation, and social media engagement. A tech enthusiast with a Computer Science degree from the University of Nairobi, he ultimately swapped code for football commentary, bringing an analytical, detail-oriented approach to his writing. Derick is convinced Wayne Rooney is the true GOAT and won’t hear otherwise!