Onana made the costly mistake but this shambolic star should never wear the United shirt again

Manchester United suffered a 1-0 defeat at the hands of Tottenham Hotspur. Here are our player ratings from the game.

(A score of 6 is around average)

Andre Onana 2 – Very poor parry into an extremely dangerous area for Tottenham’s opening strike. Distribution also not good enough.

Noussair Mazraoui 6.5 – Some decent defending to limit Son Heung-min’s threat. Incredible cross into the path of Zirkzee, which should have resulted in a goal for United.

Harry Maguire 6 – Quietly went about his job in the middle of the back three. Didn’t do much wrong.

Matthijs de Ligt 5 – Completely lost James Maddison for the opener. Needed to be more aware of his surroundings in that instance. Mostly OK after that.

Diogo Dalot 4 – Should have perhaps done better with his chance inside the box after the ball dropped to him. Just doesn’t offer enough going forward in the wing-back role. Let Son run wild down the right at times.

Casemiro 2 – Demonstrated why he rarely gets minutes for United. Constantly dispossessed, gave the ball away multiple times even under little to no pressure and allowed opposition players to easily run past him. Just doesn’t cut it at this level anymore.

Bruno Fernandes 4 – Put the ball on a plate for Garnacho, who aimed his effort well over the bar. Not as influential as he usually is and recklessly gave the ball away on a number of occasions.

Patrick Dorgu 6 – Didn’t see a lot of the ball but did well when he got on it. Looked to get forward when he could and also strong defensively.

Alejandro Garnacho 5 – Missed a clear-cut goalscoring chance to restore parity. Fired a few other shots but couldn’t beat Guglielmo Vicario. Kept passing up the opportunity to play in Dorgu on the overlap.

Joshua Zirkzee 7 – One of United’s better performers, especially in the first half. Some decent touches on the ball and did well to hold up the ball and link up play. Should have found the back of the net when he got on the end of Mazraoui’s cross but he headed it wide.

Rasmus Hojlund 3 – Struggled again. Looked a little bit better when he was drifting into wide areas.

Substitutes

Chido Obi 5 – Thrust into the pitch in added time for his senior debut. Not much he could do.

Featured image Alex Pantling via Getty Images


Follow us on Bluesky: @peoplesperson.bsky.social

Derick Kinoti is a football writer at The Peoples Person who has covered Manchester United and the game extensively for many years. He is a keen analyst with expertise in SEO and journalism standards. Derick is convinced Wayne Rooney is the true GOAT and won’t hear otherwise!

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Leny Yoro reveals what JJ Gabriel must do to succeed at United

Manchester United defender Leny Yoro has lavished praise on academy star JJ Gabriel following his senior debut against Atletico Madrid on Saturday, 1 August. The French defender started the game and helped the Red Devils secure a 2-1 comeback win in pre-season, courtesy of a Bryan Mbeumo brace. Meanwhile, Gabriel etched his name into United

Iliman Ndiaye transfer: Man United make 75 million decision

If Manchester United are to act on their interest in Iliman Ndiaye, they have now been told the key figures that could secure the transfer. Not long ago, reports emerged that Saudi Pro League side Al Hilal had identified Ndiaye as a top target. Yet while the Middle Eastern football powerhouse was prepared to spend

Elliot Anderson: The bullet Manchester United dodged

This pre-season has given us a real test of what Michael Carrick’s ball is all about, clarifying why, in missing out on Elliot Anderson, the Red Devils may have dodged a bullet. Manchester United endured a shaky start to the 2024-25 season, and by midseason, qualification for Champions League football even looked unlikely. However, a

Joshua Zirkzee: Unique swap deal opportunity on the cards

Manchester United have plans to strengthen out wide, and a unique opportunity could be up for grabs if reports from Italy are to be believed. Saturday saw Michael Carrick drop Joshua Zirkzee from the starting line-up in favour of playing Bryan Mbeumo as the striker. The Cameroonian did not disappoint, grabbing a brace, and with

Bryan Mbeumo reveals his preferred position after his brace vs Atletico Madrid

Manchester United impressed at the Strawberry Arena on Saturday, picking up a deserved 2-1 win over Atletico Madrid in their third pre-season game of the summer. Shea Lacey impressed in the No.10 position, while Michael Carrick will be pleased with the impact Bryan Mbeumo had while leading the line on his own. The head coach
spot_imgspot_img