“It’s too risky”: Ex-United star claims Emery won’t sanction permanent Rashford deal for this shocking reason

Former Manchester United goalkeeper Ben Foster has insisted Aston Villa boss Unai Emery is unlikely to sanction the permanent signing of Marcus Rashford, citing the forward’s demeanour during the first leg Champions League clash against Paris Saint-Germain.

Rashford has enjoyed a renaissance at Villa since joining them from United during the January transfer window.

He has proven to be a key player for Villa, regularly contributing in front of goal, with his most recent strike coming in Tuesday’s 2-1 defeat to Manchester City.

Rashford fell out of favour under head coach Ruben Amorim, who constantly left him out of United matchday squads but he appears to be enjoying his football once again under Emery. Villa have the option of making his stay a permanent one for £40million.

Whenever Emery has been questioned about whether the Birmingham side will trigger the option, he has remained non-committal, even though his selections have consistently shown a clear preference for Rashford over Ollie Watkins.

A report covered by The Peoples Person claimed that United could potentially use Rashford as a makeweight in a deal to land Watkins.

Now, Foster has hinted that Emery is unlikely to keep faith in Rashford beyond this season. He specifically took issue with Rashford’s demeanour and attitude during Villa’s 3-1 defeat to PSG in the first leg of their quarter-final clash. Despite that, Rashford played a pivotal role in the second leg, where Villa came close to pulling off a remarkable comeback with a 3-2 win.

Foster said on his Fozcast podcast [as quoted by the Express], “I think a lot of people saw him against PSG the other night and were like, ‘Oh my god, that’s Rashford.’ That’s what you want from him and there were glimpses, I totally agree.”

“During the first leg though, he was miles off it and he didn’t really look happy again.”

Foster explained that Emery is unlikely to keep Rashford at the expense of losing Watkins.

“I just think it’s too risky for Aston Villa and I don’t think Unai Emery would sanction it. He’s on so much wages wise at Man United, I think they are going to try and sell him because they need him for PSR [profitability and sustainability rules].”

“I don’t think Amorim really wants him around the place and he doesn’t suit the system.”

Meanwhile, United are back in action on Sunday when they go away to Bournemouth.

Featured image Michael Steele via Getty Images


Follow us on Bluesky: @peoplesperson.bsky.social

Derick Kinoti is a football writer at The Peoples Person who has covered Manchester United and the game extensively for many years. He is a keen analyst with expertise in SEO and journalism standards. Derick is convinced Wayne Rooney is the true GOAT and won’t hear otherwise!

spot_imgspot_img

Related articles

Why Atleti clash was a real benefit

Sponsor Image - white adidas Sponsor Image - white Snapdragon News MUTV Tickets United Store Membership Teams Club Stream every game Watch Tour 2026 live Subscribe to MUTV Subscribe to MUTV Bryan in blue The 2026/27 away jersey Available now Available now The goalkeeper's jersey Yours in yellow Buy online now Buy online now Related

What Carrick made of our win over Atleti

Sponsor Image - white adidas Sponsor Image - white Snapdragon News MUTV Tickets United Store Membership Teams Club Bryan in blue The 2026/27 away jersey Available now Available now The goalkeeper's jersey Yours in yellow Buy online now Buy online now Brand new United magazine issue three Europe edition Order yours Order yours Related Content

Lewis-Skelly: Why United have a shot at signing Arsenal youngster

Manchester United are exploring the possibility of signing Arsenal’s Myles Lewis-Skelly, as per reports. The Red Devils are in the market for a new left-back as they look to add much-needed width and creativity to their left flank, having failed to offload Marcus Rashford and bring in a new left winger. As such, the focus

Aurelien Tchouameni close to leaving Real Madrid as Man United lie in wait

Manchester United’s patience could be about to be rewarded if reports emerging from Spain are to be believed. The Red Devils have already signed Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans to strengthen their engine room, with the Brazilian impressing during pre-season. However, United still lack that out-and-out defensive midfielder, which explains why they were interested in

Juventus Douglas Luiz makes transfer stance clear amid Man United links

Juventus midfielder Douglas Luiz has clarified his stance on his future amid suggestions that he could be headed to Manchester United. Dream move United are on the hunt for a third midfield signing after securing the services of Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans from Chelsea and Aston Villa respectively. Michael Carrick’s side are said to
spot_imgspot_img